討論--為何*白州*雪莉比*山崎*雪莉貴一點?
討論主題:討論--為何*白州*雪莉比*山崎*雪莉貴一點? [ 其它 ]
回討論區列表WCH
評價:+155-0
等級:
回應共 35 則， 第 2 / 2 頁
WCH
評價:+155-0
WCH
評價:+155-0
onedog
評價:+143-0
WAXL
評價:+114-0
金假仙
評價:+126-0
carlos67
評價:+365-0
WCH
評價:+155-0
舒適ㄟ
評價:+7-0
WCH
評價:+155-0
湸湸
評價:+61-0
阿蒙
評價:+154-0
興大陳
評價:+58-0
penny1201
評價:+74-0
WCH
評價:+155-0
回應帳號:penny1201(penny1201)
白州不推唷, 歐美阿六都不要, 他們指認得過獎的 山崎跟響
這不是歐美和對面的不要，而是跟本就是白州還沒有舖貨在這些點。
說真的，許多前輩都說比較起白州雪莉和山崎雪莉，
白州的味道比較有層次感，也比較細緻!
加上，最後最重要的ㄧ點，白州雪莉的量因為是從2012年才發行，
2013才在台灣上市，所以在市面上的量，遠遠少於山崎雪莉。
而這點才是收藏家追逐的關鍵。
沒錯，山崎雪莉的2011的確得到了MMA金牌，
但是同ㄧ年MMA的第二名最佳雪莉桶是白州雪莉2012，
初試國際比賽，就勇奪89.14(共有七位評審)
差點翻掉老大哥山崎雪莉2011。
所有的評審都給與高度的評價！
以下是白州雪莉2012的得分以及評所給予的評論:
＿＿＿＿＿＿＿＿＿＿＿＿＿＿＿＿＿＿＿＿＿＿＿
Average Score: 89
Maniac Ratings Robert Karlsson 91 Konstantin Grigoriadis 86 Ho-cheng Yao 90 Krishna Nukala 90 David Wankel 91 Keith Wood 91 Oliver Klimek 85
Tasting Notes Robert Karlsson Big big amounts of sherry wood influence here. But still with an unusual coastalness on top of it. Seasalt? And hints of sweet berries too. Special. The taste mirrors this also. Sherry and a fresh intermingled note. Hm, intriguing and quite tasty indeed. Fresh yet massive, an almost impossible combination. Keith Wood Glass: Classic Malt - Colour: Not far removed from ebony - Nose: Now this is rich, starting with a colour not far removed from ebony to the suggestions of antique oak and leather immediately predominant on the nose. There's even a slight suggestion of wood smoke in the background whilst retaining a surprising freshness and clarity. With time in the glass an almost, but not quite, perfumed character develops. Wonderful indeed so far. - Palate: It positively explodes with big, rich, bold, even extravagant rich dark fruitiness accompanied by toasted coconut macaroons dipped in milk chocolate - Finish: Let's say all of the nose and palate in a delightfully never-ending way. - Overall Impression: What a star it is too. Big, bold, massively extravagant and yet with an underlying lightly perfumed character alongside the rich leatheriness and fruitiness on the nose. The toasted coconut macaroon effect was a delight which immediately transported me to Alsace. Meanwhile, did I just use that word "Great" it certainly is. Oliver Klimek Colour: Dark copper - Nose: Sweet cherries, prunes, toasted nuts, hints of dark chocolate and polished oak, allspice and hints of cinnamon. - Palate: Christmas pudding with brandy butter, orange zest, dark chocolate, cinnamon, allspice and nutmeg. - Finish: Long and fruity with dry spices. - Overall: This is a rather typical sherry bomb, hard to tell that it is from Japan. The nose beats the palate, but it is a high quality whisky overall.
malcolm
評價:+122-1