紫鑽假酒？？？
討論主題:紫鑽假酒？？？ [ 其它 ]
回討論區列表iwhisky
評價:+32-0
等級:gran reserva 1979 的蓋子套發現有皺摺
的是假的。請看：
http://www.whiskyfun.com/war1.html
進一步搜尋發現國外網站上的麥卡倫
12 gran reserva（台灣所稱的紫鑽）
和國外網站上所有其它款的麥卡倫
確實蓋子套都是沒有鄒摺的。
請教各位前輩對這個有什麼看法？
參考資料：
沒鄒摺
http://www.p9.com.tw/Forum/ForumTopic.aspx?Id=255600
有鄒摺
http://www.p9.com.tw/Forum/ForumTopic.aspx?Id=255554
回應共 39 則， 第 1 / 2 頁
LKT
評價:+97-0
Amophis
評價:+25-0
☆傑☆
評價:+55-2
椪柑
評價:+210-0
阿晟
評價:+172-0
頗舊惟
評價:+58-0
iwhisky
評價:+32-0
大姆哥
評價:+82-0
stevenqq
評價:+14-0
酒亨
評價:+535-0
大姆哥
評價:+82-0
iwhisky
評價:+32-0
Mike.Lin
評價:+254-0
回應帳號:iwhisky(iwhisky)
MORE ON DODGY CAPUSLES (tin foils). When spotting an awful looking capsule (large wrinkles, looseness etc.) it’s not very easy to come to conclusions. Was the bottle fondled? Was the capsule put back by hand after a refill? Or is it plain normal? The first thing to do is to check on retailers or collectors’ websites if other similar bottles display the same kind of problem. It can’t be very normal, as not all bottlers have/had state of the art bottling equipment. If they don’t, it may well still be ‘normal’, because we all know that whisky expands when exposed to higher temperatures. That may push the cork and the foil that’s over it out of the bottle a bit, and usually its owner would then try to put it back in place, causing these ‘wrinkles’ or ‘crimping’ to appear on the capsule. Such bottles should command lower prices at auctions, even when probably plain genuine, but please first check if not all known bottles display the same kind of 'problems'.
Also, we got questions about a Leapfrog Murray McDavid that had a golden capsule instead of the more common orange one. It's been confirmed by the bottler that in their early days, they used to put either capsules depending on what they had in stock (even if the golden ones are less 'common'). So, no reasons to panic here...
封籤只是其中一個辨別真偽的手段而已,
還是要從其它項目多看,才能確定
iwhisky
評價:+32-0
坪田信義
評價:+185-0
冰郎
評價:+1806-2
酒亨
評價:+535-0
iwhisky
評價:+32-0
坪田信義
評價:+185-0
酒亨
評價:+535-0