2009 Malt Maniacs Awards (MMA) 麥芽狂人獎 報!
討論主題:2009 Malt Maniacs Awards (MMA) 麥芽狂人獎 報! [ 單一純麥 ]
回討論區列表Charlie-W
評價:+9-0
等級:
回應共 79 則， 第 3 / 4 頁
Charlie-W
評價:+9-0
回應帳號:Charlie-W(chingcwang)
比利時網站對這次 2009 MMA 結果的看法:
What should we conclude from this year’s results?
- Six out of seven Gold medals are won by (heavy) sherry bottlings
- Few remarkable scores for peated whisky (except for the awards in strictly peated categories of course – is this separate treatment still relevant by the way? Why is sherry not placed in specific categories?). Also, it should be noted that the best Islay releases are from independent bottlers
- Japanese distilleries (Karuizawa, Yoichi, Hakushu) and other countries (India’s Amrut and even France’s Glan Ar Mor) are responsable for a lot of high scores
- La Maison du Whisky is doing a great job selecting casks (2 Gold medals, 6 Silver and 3 Bronze)
louisli
評價:+316-0
台灣山
評價:+0-0
迷你酒
評價:+20-0
Charlie-W
評價:+9-0
Charlie-W
評價:+9-0
回應帳號:米羅(milohsun)
查理大~~~~
這麼說來
89 Karuizawa 1982/2009 (56.1%, OB for the Number One Drinks Co, First Fill Sherry, Cask #2748)
88 Yamazaki 18yo (43%, OB, +/- 2009)
算是超值的銀牌了
米羅大, 上面那兩款 Serge 給的分數蠻高的:
91 Karuizawa 1982/2009 (56.1%, OB, First Fill Sherry, Cask #2748)
90 Yamazaki 18yo (43%, OB, +/- 2009)
米羅
評價:+8-0
米糕宏
評價:+13-0
Charlie-W
評價:+9-0
回應帳號:迷你酒(joe5490)
有收到 Karuizawa 1967 的同好請注意了:
La Maison du Whisky (LMdW) 的經理 Alexandre Vingtier 說,
今年的 MMA 沒送 Karuizawa 1967, 因為已經送幾款好酒款, 而且得到3面金牌獎.
他認為 Karuizawa 1967 和 Glenfiddich 50 yo 是2009年裡最好的威士忌.
因此, 若 LMdW 明年送 Karuizawa 1967 參加 MMA 2010 的話 .......... 
想開 Karuizawa 1967 來喝之前, 建議先查一下 Glenfiddich 50 yo 的價值. 
Charlie-W
評價:+9-0
飲酒文化
評價:+31-0
米羅
評價:+8-0
彩色盤
評價:+2-1
louisli
評價:+316-0
彩色盤
評價:+2-1
飲酒文化
評價:+31-0
Charlie-W
評價:+9-0
彩色盤
評價:+2-1
shoart
評價:+206-0
louisli
評價:+316-0