我的#1123要換酒
討論主題:我的#1123要換酒 [ 威士忌 ]
回討論區列表已結束
atica
評價:+26-0
等級:
回應共 7 則， 第 1 / 1 頁
atica
評價:+26-0
回應帳號:atica(atica88)
大師說的
#98跟#710一樣好?
In his 2013 Whisky Bible, Jim Murray was very complimentary about all five, but reserved special praise for the ’72, ’91 and ’94 vintages:
Of the 1972 cask # 710, he said: “The richness of the sherry is almost the stuff of make-believe…the delivery is of oak crashing in a forest – mighty and all-consuming…wow, this is like a big succulent bourbon matured in a top-class sherry butt. This is a malt which if you should ever chance upon, you give the guy your coat if you have not money enough; even your undergarments if it does the trick! For this is a whisky so complex, so complete, it is almost exhausting.” He gave it 96.
He commented re the 1991 cask # 3183: “Almost a coffee cake and Swiss roll marriage with grape jam for filling…mocha-flavoured Lubec marzipan notes sidle in delightfully…the light spices pulse. Tries to be syrupy and overbearing but fails miserably. Has to settle for being brilliant.” He gave it 95.
And summing up the 1994 cask # 98, he said: “Absolutely huge grape: a real Dundee cake dripping with Oloroso and Demerara…a faultless sherry butt. I had this sample in my hand as the Queen gave her address to round off her 60th anniversary celebrations: I could hardly have had a more fitting dram with which to toast her.” It also achieved a 96.
一和k
評價:+109-0
回應帳號:atica(atica88)
大師說的
#98跟#710一樣好?
............................................................................................................................................................
白袍巫師(710).聽了 大師評論後. 不發ㄧ語 k了 矮人 金霹(98) ㄧ個響頭.
可憐的 金霹只好拉著 佛倫多(1123). 遠望離逝中土的 精靈ㄧ族(木盒一版.我也哈的要死)
萊諾
評價:+328-0
atica
評價:+26-0
atica
評價:+26-0
一和k
評價:+109-0
atica
評價:+26-0